Therapeutic Effectiveness and Safety Profiles of Medications for Migraine

In the emergency department, timely and effective relief from migraine headaches is a clinical priority. Multiple medications are available, used either alone or in combination, but the optimal “migraine cocktail” remains debated. Selecting therapy requires balancing effectiveness, side effects, and the likelihood of recurrence.

Understanding the Evidence

A recent Bayesian network meta-analysis pooled results from multiple randomized trials to compare commonly used agents. While certain medications ranked higher than others in probability of benefit, the overall certainty of the evidence was graded as low to very low. This highlights the need to interpret findings cautiously and apply them in the context of individual patient characteristics and local practice.

What Are the Most Effective Agents?

Chlorpromazine given intravenously or intramuscularly emerged with the highest probability of achieving pain relief within two hours. Ketorolac, also given IV or IM, ranked among the least effective single agents.

Other agents had variable performance. Metoclopramide consistently ranked highly for reducing the need for rescue medication. Dexamethasone was among the top medications for minimizing adverse reactions and may also reduce recurrence.

Comparative Findings from Trials

In pediatric patients, prochlorperazine outperformed ketorolac, with significantly higher response rates at 60 minutes. Several adult trials comparing ketorolac and chlorpromazine showed both were effective for pain relief at two hours, though chlorpromazine was more consistently favored in meta-analytic rankings. Meta-analyses also suggested ketorolac had similar efficacy to phenothiazines and metoclopramide, though the evidence base was limited. Adding ketorolac to metoclopramide in pediatric migraine did not improve outcomes, and small studies have suggested that magnesium sulfate may outperform ketorolac for short-term pain relief.

Why This Matters

Effective migraine management in the emergency department affects more than immediate comfort. It can reduce emergency department length of stay, decrease return visits, and improve overall patient outcomes. While chlorpromazine appears to provide superior short-term pain relief, ketorolac still has a role, particularly as part of multi-drug regimens. Understanding each agent’s side effect profile remains essential, as dopamine antagonists carry risks of sedation and extrapyramidal symptoms, while NSAIDs have renal and gastrointestinal considerations.

Common Migraine Cocktails in Practice

Chlorpromazine combined with diphenhydramine is frequently used, as the diphenhydramine mitigates akathisia. Metoclopramide paired with an NSAID such as ketorolac is reasonable when dopamine antagonists are contraindicated. A single dose of dexamethasone is often added to reduce recurrence, and magnesium sulfate may be considered in refractory cases.

Key Points to Remember

Chlorpromazine appears most effective for achieving pain relief at two hours.
Ketorolac alone is among the least effective single agents, though it retains a role in combination therapy.
Prochlorperazine is more effective than ketorolac in pediatric migraine.
Adding ketorolac to metoclopramide in children does not improve outcomes.
The overall certainty of the available evidence is low, requiring clinical judgment in treatment decisions.

For further reading: Patient values and preferences when treating acute episodic migraine

Closing Summary

No universal migraine cocktail exists, but dopamine antagonists, especially chlorpromazine, have the strongest evidence for rapid relief in the emergency department. Ketorolac is less effective as a stand-alone therapy yet remains valuable when combined with other agents. Clinicians should individualize therapy by weighing efficacy, patient comorbidities, and potential adverse effects, while recognizing that the evidence base is limited and evolving.