• About
  • Masthead
  • License Content
  • Advertise
  • Press Releases
  • Newsroom
  • RSS/Email List
  • 2MM Podcast
  • Write for us
  • Contact Us
2 Minute Medicine
No Result
View All Result

No products in the cart.

Sign in
SUBSCRIBE
  • About
  • Specialties
    • All Specialties, All Recent Reports
    • Cardiology
    • Chronic Disease
    • Dermatology
    • Emergency
    • Endocrinology
    • Gastroenterology
    • Imaging and Intervention
    • Infectious Disease
    • Nephrology
    • Neurology
    • Obstetrics
    • Oncology
    • Ophthalmology
    • Pediatrics
    • Pharma
    • Preclinical
    • Psychiatry
    • Public Health
    • Pulmonology
    • Rheumatology
    • Surgery
    • Rewinds
    • The Scan
  • EvidencePulse™
  • HypeCheck™
  • AI News
  • Classics™
    • 2MM+ Online Access
    • Paperback and Ebook
  • Tools
    • NPI Registry Lookup
    • RVU Search
    • Physician Pay by Specialty
    • ICD-10 Code Lookup
    • FDA Drug Approvals
    • Drug Safety for Breastfeeding/Pregnancy
    • Clinical Guidelines
    • Medical Calculators
    • ECG Reference
      • QTc Calculator
      • Sgarbossa Criteria
      • ECG Axis Calculator
      • AV Block Helper
  • Rankings
    • Medical School Rankings
    • Residency Rankings
  • Partners
    • License Content
    • Advertise with Us
2 Minute Medicine
  • About
  • Specialties
    • All Specialties, All Recent Reports
    • Cardiology
    • Chronic Disease
    • Dermatology
    • Emergency
    • Endocrinology
    • Gastroenterology
    • Imaging and Intervention
    • Infectious Disease
    • Nephrology
    • Neurology
    • Obstetrics
    • Oncology
    • Ophthalmology
    • Pediatrics
    • Pharma
    • Preclinical
    • Psychiatry
    • Public Health
    • Pulmonology
    • Rheumatology
    • Surgery
    • Rewinds
    • The Scan
  • EvidencePulse™
  • HypeCheck™
  • AI News
  • Classics™
    • 2MM+ Online Access
    • Paperback and Ebook
  • Tools
    • NPI Registry Lookup
    • RVU Search
    • Physician Pay by Specialty
    • ICD-10 Code Lookup
    • FDA Drug Approvals
    • Drug Safety for Breastfeeding/Pregnancy
    • Clinical Guidelines
    • Medical Calculators
    • ECG Reference
      • QTc Calculator
      • Sgarbossa Criteria
      • ECG Axis Calculator
      • AV Block Helper
  • Rankings
    • Medical School Rankings
    • Residency Rankings
  • Partners
    • License Content
    • Advertise with Us
Sign in
SUBSCRIBE
2 Minute Medicine
Sign in
Subscribe
2 Minute MedicineFree on Google PlayGet
✦EvidencePulse™by 2 Minute Medicine3 reportsYou askedtop stroke trials 2026Synthesizing medical evidence...Top 2026 stroke trial results:OCEANIC — ischemic stroke: 6.2% vs 8.4%OPTION* — mRS 0–1: 43.6% vs 34.2%ORIENTAL* — mRS 0–2: 58.6% vs 46.6%*Higher sICH in intervention armsParticipants randomizedNOCEANIC12,327OPTION570ORIENTAL564Ask about guidelines or landmark trials...↑Try EvidencePulse™Ask the evidence. Get the signal.Try it now →
Home All Specialties Pulmonology

Misperceptions about prognosis among surrogates of critically ill patients

byMichael Milligan
May 21, 2016
in Pulmonology
Reading Time: 3 mins read
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

1. Discordant expectations about a critically ill patient’s prognosis were common among surrogate decision makers and were due both to a surrogate’s misunderstandings of the physician’s assessment and differences in belief systems.

2. Prognostic estimates by surrogates were significantly more accurate than random chance, but were less accurate than physician estimates.

Evidence Rating Level: 2 (Good)

Study Rundown: Critically ill patients at the end of life are often unable to make their own decisions about medical care. In these instances, family members and loved ones are called upon to act as surrogate decision makers. It has been shown that surrogates tend to be overly optimistic about the patient’s prognosis, which can lead to greater utilization of invasive treatments and delays in palliative care.

This study sought to quantify the degree of discordance among surrogates and physicians about patient prognosis, and to identify the causes of these misperceptions. Among critically ill patients without decision-making capacity, discord was identified in 53% of cases. In most instances, this discord was due to surrogates misunderstanding of the clinical assessment as well as differences in beliefs (i.e., religious beliefs, a patient’s perceived unique strengths, and more). While surrogates were able to estimate a patient’s prognosis better than random guessing, their predictions were not as accurate as a physician’s.

This study, though limited by its use of qualitative data among critically ill patients in a single ICU, indicates that there is a high prevalence of discordance about prognosis between physicians and surrogate decision makers. It follows that to improve agreement—and to potentially improve end-of-life outcomes—physicians should regularly meet with surrogates to explore their clinical understanding and belief system. This study also points to the root causes of discord and suggests possible interventions.

RELATED REPORTS

Hematologic inflammatory indices may predict prognosis in younger patients with COVID-19 but not older patients

Low bicarbonate replacement fluid may lead to a more stable acid-base profile compared with high bicarbonate replacement fluid during continuous veno-venous hemofiltration

Click to read the study in JAMA (Journal of the American Medical Association)

Relevant Reading: Advance directives and outcomes of surrogate decision making before death

In-Depth [prospective cohort]: This study enrolled physicians and surrogate decision makers involved in the care of 174 critically ill patients at a single hospital. Patients who had been in the ICU for 5 days were eligible for this study if they were on mechanical ventilation and had at least a 40% chance of dying as calculated by their APACHE-II score. A total of 229 surrogates and 99 physicians involved in the care of these patients were analyzed. Physicians recorded their prognosis as a probability that the patient would survive their hospitalization. Without conferring, surrogates also indicated their perceived prognosis, as well as their best guess of the physician’s prognosis. Misunderstandings were defined as large differences between a physician’s estimate and a surrogate’s guess at the physician’s estimate. Belief differences were defined as large differences between a surrogate’s prognosis and their guess at the physician’s prognosis. Surrogates were then interviewed about the experience.

Discordance of at least 20% difference in estimated prognosis was evident in 53% of cases (95%CI 46.8% – 59.7%). A majority (53%) of disagreements were due to both misunderstandings and belief differences. While both surrogates and physicians were able to predict prognosis more accurately than by chance alone, physicians were more accurate (c statistic 0.83 vs. 0.74, p = 0.008).

 

Image: CC/Wiki

©2016 2 Minute Medicine, Inc. All rights reserved. No works may be reproduced without expressed written consent from 2 Minute Medicine, Inc. Inquire about licensing here. No article should be construed as medical advice and is not intended as such by the authors or by 2 Minute Medicine, Inc.

Tags: intensive careprognosis
Previous Post

Diabetic foot ulcers associated with worsening cognitive decline

Next Post

Endobronchial coiling for emphysema associated with moderate improvement in exercise tolerance

RelatedReports

Novel coronavirus identified from patients with pneumonia in Wuhan, China
Chronic Disease

Hematologic inflammatory indices may predict prognosis in younger patients with COVID-19 but not older patients

August 4, 2026
Emergency

Low bicarbonate replacement fluid may lead to a more stable acid-base profile compared with high bicarbonate replacement fluid during continuous veno-venous hemofiltration

January 13, 2026
Inflammatory bowel disease collage: a calm young woman in a sweater beside a large intestine drawing and a hot water bottle
Weekly Rewinds

2 Minute Medicine Rewind November 24, 2025

November 24, 2025
Ventilator weaning collage: a calm woman in a hospital gown with a nasal cannula beside a coil of ventilator tubing
Career Development

The Yang-Tobin Index: A Key Predictor for Successful Extubation in Critical Care

October 7, 2025
Next Post

Endobronchial coiling for emphysema associated with moderate improvement in exercise tolerance

Aspirin does not decrease the incidence of ARDS in at-risk patients

Seasonal temperature variations may affect glucose tolerance in pregnancy

✦ EvidencePulse™ by 2 Minute Medicine 3 reports You asked top stroke trials 2026 Synthesizing medical evidence... Top 2026 stroke trial results: OCEANIC — ischemic stroke: 6.2% vs 8.4% OPTION* — mRS 0–1: 43.6% vs 34.2% ORIENTAL* — mRS 0–2: 58.6% vs 46.6% *Higher sICH in intervention arms Participants randomizedN OCEANIC 12,327 OPTION 570 ORIENTAL 564 Ask about guidelines or landmark trials... Try EvidencePulse™ Get the signal. Try it now → Physician-trained medical AI by 2 Minute Medicine

2MM+ All Access

Full details →
$4.99 /month

3-day free trial · cancel anytime

  • ✓100+ physician-written reports
  • ✓EvidencePulse™ + HypeCheck™
  • ✓Ad-free reading + newsletters
Start 3-day free trial

Then $4.99/month. Manage renewal in your account.

2 Minute Medicine® is an award winning, physician-run, expert medical media company. Our content is curated, written and edited by practicing health professionals who have clinical and scientific expertise in their field of reporting. Our editorial management team is comprised of highly-trained MD physicians. Join numerous brands, companies, and hospitals who trust our licensed content.

Recent Reports

  • PROT-001 was generally safe and well tolerated in a phase 1 study of healthy volunteers with AL amyloidosis
  • 2MM: AI Roundup- PTSD Prediction, Gait as a Biomarker, Faster Cardiac MRI, and Perinatal Mental Health Chatbots [November 12th, 2026]
  • Large genetic association study identifies additional Alzheimer disease risk loci and candidate pathways
License Content
Terms of Use | Disclaimer
Cookie Policy

Get the app

Read 2 Minute Medicine on iPhone, iPad and Android.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
QR code for www.2minutemedicine.com/app
On a computer? Scan this with your phone’s camera.
2MM+ All Access Full details →

The medical literature, distilled daily.

Monthly plan selected: $4.99 /month.

$4.99/month

3-day free trial · cancel anytime

Start 3-day free trial

Then $4.99/month. Manage renewal in your account.

Yearly plan selected: $49.90 /year.

$49.90/year

2 months free

Start 3-day free trial

Then $49.90/year.

Membership benefits

  • ✓100+ new physician-written study summaries monthly, 12,000+ searchable
  • ✓AI EvidencePulse™ + HypeCheck™
  • ✓Ad-free reading + newsletters
  • ✓FDA drug approvals + clinical calculators

Already a member? Sign in

  • Get the app
  • About
  • Specialties
    • All Specialties, All Recent Reports
    • Cardiology
    • Chronic Disease
    • Dermatology
    • Emergency
    • Endocrinology
    • Gastroenterology
    • Imaging and Intervention
    • Infectious Disease
    • Nephrology
    • Neurology
    • Obstetrics
    • Oncology
    • Ophthalmology
    • Pediatrics
    • Pharma
    • Preclinical
    • Psychiatry
    • Public Health
    • Pulmonology
    • Rheumatology
    • Surgery
    • Rewinds
    • The Scan
  • EvidencePulse™
  • HypeCheck™
  • AI News
  • Classics™
    • 2MM+ Online Access
    • Paperback and Ebook
  • Tools
    • NPI Registry Lookup
    • RVU Search
    • Physician Pay by Specialty
    • ICD-10 Code Lookup
    • FDA Drug Approvals
    • Drug Safety for Breastfeeding/Pregnancy
    • Clinical Guidelines
    • Medical Calculators
    • ECG Reference
      • QTc Calculator
      • Sgarbossa Criteria
      • ECG Axis Calculator
      • AV Block Helper
  • Rankings
    • Medical School Rankings
    • Residency Rankings
  • Partners
    • License Content
    • Advertise with Us
No Result
View All Result

© 2026 2 Minute Medicine, Inc. - Physician-written medical news.